Why this conversation matters — the human cost of non-affirming theology, and the evidence that the church's current teaching is causing serious harm.
"No one changes their orientation; it doesn't happen. No therapy, no ministry, no prayer meeting, no nothing — you cannot change your sexual orientation."
For decades, many churches promoted "ex-gay" ministries — also known as conversion therapy — as the faithful Christian response to gay and bisexual people. This approach rested on the belief that people could essentially choose not to be gay if they worked hard enough, or prayed hard enough.
In 2013, the leading ex-gay organization in the world, Exodus International, closed its doors after its president acknowledged that 99.9% of people he knew had failed to change their sexual orientation. In the years since, Chambers has only grown more absolute: in a 2019 interview, he stated plainly, "No one changes their orientation; it doesn't happen."
Many other former ex-gay leaders — from Michael Bussee to John Paulk to John Smid — have similarly renounced the ex-gay movement and now affirm gay and bisexual Christians.
For generations, gay and bisexual Christians were told their orientation was something to be overcome. That premise has been abandoned even by those who once championed it.
"The potential risks of reparative therapy are great, including depression, anxiety and self-destructive behavior… Therefore, the American Psychiatric Association opposes any psychiatric treatment such as reparative or conversion therapy."
A 2018 study on conversion therapy found striking results: gay and bisexual youth whose parents tried to change their sexual orientation were more than twice as likely to attempt suicide as those whose parents did not. When young people were also sent to therapists and religious leaders who sought to change their orientation, they were nearly three times as likely to attempt suicide.
The weight of this evidence is why so many former ex-gay leaders have not only renounced their former beliefs, but apologized publicly to the communities they harmed.
The harms extend beyond conversion therapy. Condemnations of same-sex relationships and transgender people have created a crushing burden of shame in the lives of countless gay, bisexual, and transgender Christians — fostering alienation from God, the church, and family.
According to a landmark 2009 study, when families reject their gay or bisexual children, those children are 8.4 times more likely to attempt suicide, 5.9 times more likely to experience high levels of depression, and 3.4 times more likely to use illegal drugs than gay or bisexual children from supportive families.
A 2018 study found that while religious faith generally protects against suicidal thoughts and attempts among heterosexual youth, it was associated with significantly higher rates of suicidal thoughts and attempts among gay, lesbian, and questioning youth.
Even when Christian families seek to communicate their non-affirming convictions in the most loving and supportive ways possible, the results can be devastating. We strongly encourage any Christian parents grappling with their child's identity to read "Just Because He Breathes" — Linda and Rob Robertson's heartbreaking account of the consequences of their non-affirming beliefs on their son Ryan, despite their profound love and care for him.
The harms documented here are not the inevitable cost of faithfulness to the Bible. We believe Scripture, read carefully and honestly, leads to the full inclusion of gay, bisexual, and transgender Christians. The Biblical Case presents ten arguments from Scripture — each one a reason the church's traditional reading can and should change.
Matthew Vines' foundational book, delivered week by week with reflection questions and community support.